Lisa

When I was single, I used to scour my date’s bookshelves and movie collection to see if we’d be a compatible match. You can tell a lot about a person from the movies and books they choose to keep in their home, I reasoned.

I remember going out with one guy who I didn’t feel like I hit it off with. But when we got back to his apartment I saw that he had a copy of Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus and The Little Prince on his bookshelf. When I asked him about the former, he blushed, “I didn’t have sisters growing up, so I figure I’m behind the curve when it comes to understanding women.” He kept the latter because his mother read it to him as a child. Our bookshelf conversation saved the not-so-exciting date and lead to another.

Tagg had about half his book collection on display when we first started dating. I loved that he had a copy of the Apocrypha, of Ovid’s Metamorphoses and of Eats, Shoots and Leaves. (I actually started to fall for him based on the way he punctuated his text messages. “This man knows how to use a comma,” I gushed to a friend. Yes, I am a huge nerd.)

I knew he had more books in storage, but until this week, I hadn’t seen them. Yesterday—as I really started to unpack post-move—I decided to tackle those 20 book boxes.

A sampling of the titles I came across:

Another Bullsh*t Night in Suck City
The Assertiveness Workbook
The Magician: His Training and his Work (Non-fiction.)
Religion and the Decline of Magic
Who Will Run the Frog Hospital? (This is actually a great book. But the title sounds a little odd—especially when it’s next to a book on magic.)
Blackjack for Blood (Again, non-fiction!!)

Here’s the problem: I know that we’re not crazy, but our bookshelves are in our front room. We just moved to Arizona. We’re trying to make couple friends. So we’re basically 4-way dating now.

“Tagg, what are people going to think when they sit down and look at the titles on our bookshelf?” I asked.

Tagg just shrugged, “Don’t blame me. You’re the one with the polygamy books.”

“I’m Mormon. It’s normal to have books on church history. It is NOT normal to have books on magic.”

Tagg looked at me and smiled, “Yeah, I guess you’re right. It’s not like anyone in our church history was a treasure hunter or anything.”

Point taken.

Readers, make me feel better. Tell me all the crazy titles that are sitting on your/your spouse’s/your date’s bookshelf.

And, if you happen to move here, please still be our friend.