Lisa
When I was single, I used to scour my date’s bookshelves and movie collection to see if we’d be a compatible match. You can tell a lot about a person from the movies and books they choose to keep in their home, I reasoned.
I remember going out with one guy who I didn’t feel like I hit it off with. But when we got back to his apartment I saw that he had a copy of Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus and The Little Prince on his bookshelf. When I asked him about the former, he blushed, “I didn’t have sisters growing up, so I figure I’m behind the curve when it comes to understanding women.” He kept the latter because his mother read it to him as a child. Our bookshelf conversation saved the not-so-exciting date and lead to another.
Tagg had about half his book collection on display when we first started dating. I loved that he had a copy of the Apocrypha, of Ovid’s Metamorphoses and of Eats, Shoots and Leaves. (I actually started to fall for him based on the way he punctuated his text messages. “This man knows how to use a comma,” I gushed to a friend. Yes, I am a huge nerd.)
I knew he had more books in storage, but until this week, I hadn’t seen them. Yesterday—as I really started to unpack post-move—I decided to tackle those 20 book boxes.
A sampling of the titles I came across:
Another Bullsh*t Night in Suck City
The Assertiveness Workbook
The Magician: His Training and his Work (Non-fiction.)
Religion and the Decline of Magic
Who Will Run the Frog Hospital? (This is actually a great book. But the title sounds a little odd—especially when it’s next to a book on magic.)
Blackjack for Blood (Again, non-fiction!!)
Here’s the problem: I know that we’re not crazy, but our bookshelves are in our front room. We just moved to Arizona. We’re trying to make couple friends. So we’re basically 4-way dating now.
“Tagg, what are people going to think when they sit down and look at the titles on our bookshelf?” I asked.
Tagg just shrugged, “Don’t blame me. You’re the one with the polygamy books.”
“I’m Mormon. It’s normal to have books on church history. It is NOT normal to have books on magic.”
Tagg looked at me and smiled, “Yeah, I guess you’re right. It’s not like anyone in our church history was a treasure hunter or anything.”
Point taken.
Readers, make me feel better. Tell me all the crazy titles that are sitting on your/your spouse’s/your date’s bookshelf.
And, if you happen to move here, please still be our friend.






48 comments
Comments feed for this article
February 2, 2010 at 11:07 am
karen
I can’t really say we have any peculiar titles on our shelves. But what I will say is this: If I saw all of those titles on one bookshelf, I would definitely be looking forward to some very interesting conversations.
And – at least the boy reads! I don’t think my husband has read a book for pleasure since I married him.
February 2, 2010 at 11:18 am
Living in zion
I agree with Karen. Variety is the spice of life. And I have a husband who doesn’t read. The good news is all the bookshelves in our house are mine and I am free to fill them with whatever I want.
I do believe strongly in genetic influence and example. For instance, two out of our three kids read like crazy. I am so proud! They take after me. The other reads a lot on the computer, but I am just old enough I don’t think that counts. My husband watches tv. All three kids love, love, love tv.
So they have both of us in them.
Anyone who comes to your house will probably be intimidated by your bookshelves. I know I would.
February 2, 2010 at 11:25 am
Living in zion
p.s. Whatever you do, don’t make the mistake my brother and sister-in-law made. I accidentally learned all about marital relations because they had a book on their shelf with a title of something about pioneers (sorry, can’t remember) and I started to read it. Turned out to be a guide for newlyweds. This book was on their shelf in the living room, next to the family hymnal and Mormon Doctrine! The bishop could have picked it up while visiting…too embarrassing to consider.
It took a long time for me to look either my brother or his wife in the eye after that.
February 2, 2010 at 11:30 am
Rebecca
If you haven’t, read Ex Libris: Confessions of a Common Reader. The first essay is Marrying Libraries, and it’s awesome. (Also, forgive my lack of punctuation for the titles. Chrome doesn’t seem to support italics in comment boxes.)
Also, I’m a bit sad to say that a person who looks at my book shelf will likely conclude that (1) I’m too lazy to return text books, (2) I’m too cheap to buy books that aren’t text books, and (3) I sort of have a crush on my local library.
February 2, 2010 at 11:30 am
Megan
Heck! I want to be your friend now. And I’m really curious, who IS going to run the frog hospital? I’d volunteer but I’m kinda busy right now.
February 2, 2010 at 11:44 am
Rachel A.
We have two copies of Getting to Yes, what does that tell you?
You can come hang out with us, we’re relatively normal and moved from the east coast to Arizona. Plus, I’m related to Louise so she can vouch that I’m not a psycho.
February 2, 2010 at 11:46 am
gamma
I am the bookworm of the family, and as I have justly observed, I do not have too many books, I just don’t have enough bookshelves. However, my husband has a statistically representative number of books to his own credit. Most are books of his own choosing; other are gifts from the kids. So he has Church books, about which he is extremely particular, business books, economic books, and astrophysics books, with a sprinkling of golf books here and there. And “It Takes a Village Idiot” by Jim Mullen, which is a favorite of our family and almost everyone has a copy. They are in his office, safe from commentary or note from random individuals.
We do position ourselves (to borrow a business term) with our reading, and not just on a bookshelf. When my husband was asked in an interview to name a book he had read recently, he considered which one of the several possibilities would sound most professional. It’s one way of putting our best foot forward.
Luckily, you didn’t ask about what crazy titles I have.
February 2, 2010 at 11:54 am
Erin
Lisa, if you have not already read it, I think you would love the book “Ex Libris: Confessions of a Common Reader” by Anne Fadiman (how do you italicize words in comments? Can you?)
In one chapter she talks about the odd shelf—”on this shelf rests a small, mysterious corpus of volumes whose subject matter is completely unrelated to the rest of the library, yet which, upon closer inspection, reveals a good deal about its owner.” Her Odd Shelf consisted of books on polar exploration. She cites other odd shelves, including Philip Larkin’s Odd Shelf “crammed with pornography, with an emphasis on spanking.”
It looks like you may have discovered Tagg’s Odd Shelf.
February 2, 2010 at 11:56 am
CSIowa
When I was a newlywed in graduate school, I invited a literature professor over for dinner with me and my husband. My professor was largely responsible for the selection of what I had on my bookshelf, so I hadn’t given it a second thought. The one he chose to comment on–over pork chops, applesauce and sauerkraut–was Tim and Beverly LaHaye’s The Act of Marriage. I must have turned three shades of crimson when he said, “That is a good book.” But he was right. It is.
Another more recent favorite of mine on that particular subject is And They Were Not Ashamed by Brotherson. It’s on my fireplace mantel with several other books, mostly scriptures and church pamphlets. It doesn’t bother me at all these days, but I think it mortifies my teenagers that it is there. Maybe that’s not quite as horrifying as when they actually saw me reading it.
February 2, 2010 at 11:56 am
Marilyn
We have plenty of titles that would raise eyebrows, such as “Is Sex Necessary?” (Thurber). But the titles that would prompt hearty guffaws from those who know me (and uncomfortable silence from those who don’t) are the 15-20 books on household management, with titles such as “How to Clean Everything” and “Organize NOW!” It’s much more fun to read about a clean house than to achieve one.
(And would somebody please tell me how to create/format italics when commenting on blog posts?)
February 2, 2010 at 11:57 am
Erin
Ok, during the time I took to write my comment, Rebecca stole my thunder.
February 2, 2010 at 12:25 pm
nakiru
YES to the Ex Libris book!!! (Italics are accomplished by before and after (without the quotes and spaces.))
My boyfriend (wow, that feels weird to say) suggested that I read three books specifically. Of Mice and Men, The Stand (Stephen King), and Don Quixote, the last of which was billed as his favorite book. A strange mix, I felt. Later, I discovered that the books he actually owns are limited to Don Quixote, old textbooks and an assortment of Stephen King. He doesn’t save most books, he reads them and passes them on. Crazy, since I hoard books like the apocalypse is coming tomorrow to wipe out the public library system. He thinks this is insane and views my overwhelmed bookshelves with some distrust.
Rightly so, since Shakespeare and Greek textbooks are housed next to books about language theory, and books about crude slang in Ancient Greece sit next to books about liturgical worship. So…I have no room to judge.
As for the frog hospital book, is Tagg a Lorrie Moore fan in general? I have read some of her stuff, but was slightly put off by her MFA overuse of flowery descriptions and over-explanations. (Sorry MFAs out there. I’m sure you don’t have these problems.)
Going to shut up now….
February 2, 2010 at 12:27 pm
nakiru
Sigh. The symbol that is above the comma, the letter “i”, followed by the symbol above the period – to close, repeat and just insert a backslash before the “i”. Hope that actually helps.
February 2, 2010 at 12:43 pm
Rachel E.
Lisa- you know my house. I’m at my desk and I’m turning around to type some titles on my top shelves (because the lowest are for the kids).
Here we go:
-Wicked
-Fast Food Nation haven’t/probably never will read it
-Barbara Bush’s Memoirs
-My FBI by Louis Freeh
-Ghandi
-Lord of the Rings
-A Patricia Cornwell book (can’t see title from here)
-Night by Elie Weisel
-Old Man and The Sea
-A Mind at a Time (an understanding how your child learns book by a guy who was later charged with child molestation…see “Fast Food Nation”)
-The companion book to the J. Paul Getty museum in So. Cal
And because if you haven’t wondered, you will, all my Twilight books are up stairs.I keep them close. Just like expensive jewelry.
February 2, 2010 at 1:27 pm
mmiles
There’s only one solution, buy him Early Mormonism and the Magic World View
February 2, 2010 at 1:40 pm
Meredith
I think Tagg should continue reading about magic. It sounds weird, but my brother can do amazing magic tricks, and even joined the National Brotherhood of Magicians in high school (stop laughing). He is a hit with all his nieces and nephews, as well as their parents. You might remember Nick from our ward at BYU Lisa. SO not dorky, right? He just happens to have an interesting talent that not many people know about.
We have some books on marriage on our shelves. We got them as wedding presents, and they’ve never been opened. Maybe we’ll crack them when our mid-life crises hit.
February 2, 2010 at 1:54 pm
rvs
I love snooping on other people’s bookshelves. I always wish I had more space for more books, but currently I’ve got a varied collection including:
Freakonomics
Superfreakonomics
A Series of Unfortunate Events, Book One (In French)
Le Petit Nicolas
Moby Dick
Rough Stone Rolling
Cat’s Cradle
The Book Thief
… and then my textbooks, on government, law, and political novels.
Great post, Lisa. Thanks!
February 2, 2010 at 1:58 pm
Kahalia
How funny, living in zion. Friends and I were just talking about how there needs to be an LDS sex book for honeymooners with straight-forward advice including details and mechanics.
February 2, 2010 at 2:04 pm
Sharon
On one of the two shelves in my living room I have Dr. Seuss, musical scores, lots of language dictionaries, Aristotle, Foucault (you can tell I was in grad school not too long ago), lots of Shakespeare, lots of Marlowe, Catcher in the Rye, Jonathan Edwards, The Federalist Papers, and yearbooks from the middle school where I taught, to name a few. I also collect Books of Mormon in different languages, so there’s a growing stripe of dark blue on two of my shelves.
My roommate is a marriage and family therapist. I wouldn’t really care, but she keeps Intimacy and Desire, The Dance of Intimacy, and The New Sex Therapy on the shelf in her bedroom.
Religion and the Decline of Magic is a really cool book.
February 2, 2010 at 2:05 pm
Kathy
We have magic books, too. They belong to my husband…along with the card trick books. Our collection of books is eclectic to say the least: classic literature, mythology, Russian lit, literary analysis books, finance and accounting books, modern lit and more. We love books. We hoard books. We need to buy more bookshelves.
My favorite books in our collection anything and everything from both Mark Twain and Charles Dickens to The Work and The Glory series and The Great and the Terrible series. My husband will never read any of these books, but, fortunately, we have books suited for his taste, too.
Oh…I bought “Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus” at the beginning of our relationship. It caused ridiculous amounts of fighting in our newly formed relationship and was the only book I ever wanted to burn.
February 2, 2010 at 2:07 pm
Liz
I don’t have very many books yet. YET
Most of the ones I do have are books about industrial design or art history that I bought for my college courses, but I love the idea of owning books. I think I would be willing to buy books with no intention of reading them just so I could have them in my home (although this post might make me reconsider what message I’m sending out.) I love little bookstores and rooms crammed to the gills with books, making use of every available inch of wall and floor space for shelving. I love books shelved in strange locations like on a rafter beam or staircase.
February 2, 2010 at 2:29 pm
Mercedes
1. have you guys read jonathan strange and mr. norrell? if you are into magic, it is a pure delight. i actually squealed while reading it. i can’t decide what i liked more, the novel itself or the copious footnotes.
2. my husband is a bookshelf hog. our entire front room is full of his books which include things like:
the entire britannica “great book” collection
no man knows my history
a huge collection of books on the cossacks
the origin of species
a huge collection of books on law and economics (very dry stuff if you ask me)
3. based on your bookshelf profile, i think my husband and i would like to date you and your husband.
February 2, 2010 at 2:30 pm
Nancy
Sorry – what or who is MFA?
Our book shelves, DVD and CD shelves would say that we (the collective family) either have several split personalities between us or are simply ‘well-rounded,’ as they are all over the place in genre. I am an avid library user, but will buy a book that I love – or is simply too good a deal to pass up. Even so, we have run out of shelves and I have several stacks going. When I suggested to my husband recently that I would like to make/get more shelves, there was some definite eye-rolling happening. The only book I was somewhat embarrassed to have on my shelf was an early edition of ‘Fascinating Womanhood.’ I did get rid of it during a book culling last year.
February 2, 2010 at 2:43 pm
lisapiorczynski
Oh my gosh. These comments are awesome. I’ve got to run to an appointment, but I promise to be back before the end of the day to give you all proper responses.
Team Apron Stage rocks.
February 2, 2010 at 3:05 pm
corktree
My husband was woefully unread when we met, and the only book that I recall on his book shelf was a copy of “Dune”. He claimed it wasn’t for lack of desire necessarily, but he just really wasn’t exposed in his small New England high school. There were so many books that I thought were required reading that he had never even heard of! So when we merged our lives, I quickly introduced him to my budding collection and he politely obliged by reading anything I suggested…and ended up loving almost everything he read! It felt like a gamble in our relationship. I mean, we had so many other areas where we connected, but I wasn’t sure how I would feel later on if he didn’t like anything that I did in literature. He even read “The lovely bones” with me and wants to see the movie, which feels a bit weird, but I’ll take it.
He now considers “Fahrenheit 451″ one of his favorites, and over the years has introduced me to some interesting selections like “Freakonomics” and “Blink”. I’m glad I pushed him a bit and didn’t just accept that I was the only book lover in the family.
And I really like the idea of having a book shelf that highlights aspects of your lives and interests, and keeping the weird stuff (sex and magic included) on a bedroom bookshelf. Or at least just pick ONE of each of those genres to showcase and show your depth
I have some decorative shelves downstairs for the inevitable “snoopers” (I’m definitely a book snooper) that has at least one of each of my favorite authors and genres – just to give people a taste of who I am that they wouldn’t know otherwise.
February 2, 2010 at 3:10 pm
corktree
Oh, and “Ex Libris” is next on my reading list! I just read Fadiman’s “The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down” ( a MUST read) and loved it. It’s apparent from her superb writing that she must be well read. I can’t wait!
February 2, 2010 at 3:15 pm
Kaylee
We have “Improvised Munitions Handbook 1969″ right next to “How to Teach Your Baby to Read.” What a good thing to teach my baby to read… The books happen to be about the same height and we have limited shelf space. Also, my husband likes army surplus stores.
February 2, 2010 at 3:22 pm
Beth
There is a book on sex that my Mormon Bishop recommended. It is called “The Act of Marriage.” It was written by a Baptist minister and his wife and is from the point of view of someone waiting until marriage. Good book, could probably help a lot of people out.
I’m just saying…
February 2, 2010 at 3:26 pm
corktree
Also, I’m not really saying sex and magic are “weird”, (I own a few myself), just that I’d rather not have to wonder what impression others have, or have to explain. I HAVE been known to pass my copy of Brotherson’s book around to people that have hinted at having issues – with good results, but THAT’s a weird feeling.
February 2, 2010 at 3:46 pm
Amanda
That’s ok, when my husband was taking his development and A&P courses in medical school, I would often come home to find text books open on the dining room table with graphic pictures of male and female genitalia on display.
Nothing like that image to welcome you and your guests home.
February 2, 2010 at 3:51 pm
angie f
I have five kids. Both my husband and I are confirmed geeks. I’m a little bit more of a book geek than he is, but he is just as attached to his books as I am. I think we had been married for more than five years before I could “safely” give away extra copies of books that we both brought to our marriage (Les Miserables, Huck Finn, Anna Karenina for example). We now have books in almost every room of our house. The kitchen has a whole shelf of the pantry with cookbooks. The living room has art books, piano books and a strange assortment of Asian History, Russian History, American History, politics and popular fiction (Toni Morrison). The family room has Austen, LDS religion books (McConkie, CES, Talmage, Nibley), Russian lit, Dan Brown, JK Rowling, Tolkein, Riverside Shakespeare, and the entire Will and Ariel Durant collection, for example. The office houses all the law books and family history books. Upstairs, we have board books, picture books, beginning chapter books, girl fiction, boy fiction, popular fiction, classical fiction, french, russian and portuguese (in respective languages) fiction. We have both the LaHaye book and the Brotherson book and much much more. Our books upstairs are in double rows and stacked upon stacks, on top of nightstands (I covet the Levenger’s nightstands that are actually bookshelves). And I try really hard not to buy books I don’t already love now. It is a sickness. I don’t know that I would have any embarrassment of anyone seeing any of our books. I had a roommate in college who begged me to put my women’s health books out of the living room–it embarrassed her. That I could never figure out; were we trying to hide our gender? But then she was embarrassed to buy feminine hygiene products too.
I guess we don’t have anything truly strange, sorry Lisa. Our shelves just shout our very pronounced book geek status to the world.
February 2, 2010 at 3:55 pm
Miggy
Maybe it’s not the content of our bookshelf, but the combination…
Ramona the Brave
Slaughterhouse 5
4 Arguments for the elimination of Television
Any and all CS Lewis
Danny the Champion of the World
The Mole People {pretty much required reading if you live in NYC}
Flags of our Fathers
The Man who Loved Only Numbers
Anna Karenina
Robinson Crusoe
I’m also more partial to non-fiction than the hubs… but for me it wasn’t books as much as music. If a guy wasn’t into the same music it was over.
February 2, 2010 at 4:01 pm
Traci
I think I might be the odd man out of this conversation. I D.I. my books once I’ve read them (my mom is an almost clinical level pack rat, I break out into hives now at the thought of lots of things I don’t use anymore filling my house). I only keep the books I will reread, books whose bindings are very pretty or books I have mormon guilt about chucking. I can’t give away any of my Deseret Book books, what if I have to give a talk? OK, I probably would look up articles and quotes on the internet, but still, it’s like turning my back on my religion. That said I’m sure I appear FAR more religious than I am.
February 2, 2010 at 4:08 pm
Traci
I sould say I appear extremely religious and beyond that illiterate.
February 2, 2010 at 4:23 pm
Cheryl
Since contemplating getting my master’s in sex therapy, I have bought all the LDS books on the topic I could find. I wanted to know what was out there. (The best one I have found is called “And They Were Not Ashamed” by Laura Brotherson – I HIGHLY recommend it to anyone getting married or even if you are married. It also has a great section on there about teaching your kids about sex and what is appropriate to teach at what age. Great book!)
A few weeks ago, I had a friend over who noticed all the books on my end table. I could tell by the expression on her face, she wondered if I was using these books to help me in my marriage. I told her, “Oh these are not for me,” but I could tell by the look on her face she thought otherwise. Okay, awkward! (I gues that is when I should have gone into my spiel about how I am considering going back to school… blah, blah, blah…)
February 2, 2010 at 9:21 pm
Rebecca
100 (1000? 200?) Questions LDS Couples should ask before marriage
FYI, its a GREAT road trip book. No matter if its a couple traveling, or just a car of girls. The things they expect you to ask someone before marriage cracked me up. And yes, I owned that book for a while before dating my husband but never used it until after we were married. Even then some of the questions left us stumped.
I keep that book next to my Love Letters (analyzing handwriting) book, and my palm reading book. Of course Dr. Seuss and random children’s books are the majority of our book shelves these days.
February 2, 2010 at 9:43 pm
Tiffany Gee Lewis
I’m so glad there are others out there who make bookshelf sifting part of their friend/boyfriend protocol. In college, if I ever walked into a guy’s apartment and saw a shelf loaded with “How to Make a Million Bucks By 30″-type books, I knew it would never work out.
“Ex Libris” is a book I read yearly. That woman speaks to my book-lover soul.
February 2, 2010 at 9:58 pm
CSIowa
I also have five kids. I’m impressed by angie f and wonder how she manages to know where all the books in her house are. Ours travel around so much that I would go insane (and have, so I stopped) trying to keep them all organized. That’s what I get for having several voracious readers. I’ll settle for off the floor. By the way, books are a key building material for blanket forts–the thicker and heavier the better–so keeping them off the floor is still a struggle. Is there better use for Joyce’s Ulysses?
February 2, 2010 at 11:13 pm
Kelly
The Real Gworge Washington, When Character Was King, The entire Louis L’Amour Sckett series, everything that Robin McKinley ever wrote, the Harry Potter series, The Encyclopedia of Container Gardening, and I refuse to tell you what is in the boxes underneath my bed, but I will tell you they are my favorite authors and get me throught the winter. And Lisa, If I lived in Arizona, I would SO be your friend…but I refuse to feel sorry for you. You have Tader Joes and In n Out Burger.
February 2, 2010 at 11:13 pm
meg Fee
i might just be your biggest fan, i love how you write.
a few of my best:
the guide to getting it on
sextrology
your perfect right
the power of intention
(really proud of my myriad of self-help books {cringe}).
good luck with the four-way dating scene!
February 2, 2010 at 11:15 pm
sar
To make a good impression you need to get an old hardback edition of “The Rise and Fall of the 3rd Reich.” It’s a nice fat book with a big swastika on the spine. Otherwise, the best book title we’ve got is “The Anatomy of Human Destructiveness”.
February 2, 2010 at 11:46 pm
angie f
CSIowa, you read far more order into my life than really exists. The downstairs books are fairly easy to catalog (except for tracking down who is re-reading which Harry Potter at present or where certain church books have gone to when lesson prep time comes around). The upstairs books are everywhere. Every room has books and I’m never quite sure which are where. A friend wanted to borrow my Ender’s Game and I couldn’t find it for months, thought I’d lent it to another friend, found it at my mother’s house (in VA, I live in Vegas) many months later. She had borrowed it to read on a plane home and then just shelved it at her house. I have no such pretenses about keeping books off floors. My only rule is to try and keep them out of water (not always possible as our Anne of Green Gables’ water fattened state can attest to) My current favorite place to find books is by the stack in the top bunk of my boys’ room–he sleeps with books
sar, our Rise and Fall is a paperback, but still a rather ominous black and red. Apparently we should aspire to something scarier.
February 2, 2010 at 11:48 pm
angie f
that is, my oldest son, who sleeps in the top bunk, sleeps with books. I really don’t know if the bunk bed itself sleeps with our without books.
February 3, 2010 at 3:53 am
E.B.
I had three different roommates who ended up with “The Dance of Anger” while living with me. Was I the cause? Enabler? I love going through my parents’ bookshelf when I am home. A personal favorite was “Teaching Your Children How to Think.” Seriously? As to my shelf, the clear winner is definitely “Hold my Gold: A White Girl’s Guide to the Hip-Hop World.”
February 3, 2010 at 5:52 am
smylies
Several years ago I was in an airport bookstore, a delayed flight, so I sat on the floor and started reading “Bringing Down the House” about MIT kids turned gamblers. I would give it a high rating on the trash scale. I am happy to report that I finished the book after finding it on Tagg’s bookshelf.
Not happy to report that I think we still have it. A book thief. What is worse? What do people think when they see it on my shelf?
February 3, 2010 at 1:39 pm
Kaedi
Rebecca, why in the world didn’t you pass that on to me?!? How did I end up with just the Traveling pants series?!? Geesh!
February 3, 2010 at 1:49 pm
Miggy
Smylies–
I too have Bringing Down the House. Yes! After a couple chapters I read with a black marker so I could black out all the bad words. However, I found the actual story intriguing.
February 4, 2010 at 1:40 am
Louise Plummer
Lisa, from my beddy I can see a book titled “Clutter Solutions” by Good Housekeeping magazine. It looks like it’s never been opened.