Levi and I—we’re tired. For the first time since we’ve been married, we’re having a hard time reaching consensus (at least about something important) and the stakes at hand make our diverging opinions feel like kind of a big deal.
I’ve always thought it unfair the number of big decisions people our age have to make. Isn’t there a place, say five years from now, where we just live the lives we’ve been deciding about for the past decade? Because it really is exhausting—all this choosing things right now that will ultimately determine whether we end up in Michigan or Mongolia; in passages of hounding regret or blissfully happy.
Who to marry. What to study. Where to live. Where to work. How to live. Because we have to decide all of that right this minute, don’t we?
The particular choice at hand feels like roads diverging, which is hard enough. But it’s complicated because we’re two travelers who decided to always walk together, and after a lot of personal and careful consideration on this matter, we didn’t chose the same path. Levi wants to go left, I want to go right.
Which means we’ve spent the past couple of weeks trying to convince each other to switch platforms. And trying to convince ourselves that we’re not being selfish by pushing our own agendas. And then deciding it is selfishness and meeting up at the end of day and saying to each other—at the same time—I’ll walk with you. Then trying to convince each other that we’d both be happier doing what the other person wants. Until we find ourselves back at that place where again, we each want two different things. Like I said, we’re tired.
There’s a story in the Book of Mormon that a lot of Mormons read when they have to make a choice. It’s about a man who goes to God with two specific problems. God solves the first one, but sends the man to come up with his own solution to the second, in effect promising to help and bless whatever solution the man comes up with.
Levi and I, we’ve tried both approaches. We went to God and asked for solutions for almost a year, and no definitive feedback to speak of, we assumed He would bless whatever we came up with.
So we’ve brainstormed. We’ve been to the temple. We’ve fasted. We’ve listed and ranked the options. Weighed the pros and cons. Stayed up late. Conceded. Held fast. Listened. Cried. Argued. Sank. Pumped our fists. And this week, we smashed head first into a deadline. We had to make a decision by Tuesday morning. (Or else.)
So on Saturday we spent three hours with a marriage counselor. (Okay fine, it was one of my best friends who doubles as a therapist. The things we ask our friends to do for us…)
On Sunday, anytime we found ourselves alone, we looked at each other and though we didn’t want to, asked the same question. “What are we going to do?” Sunday night, we fell asleep on the couch, on the verge of depression, at 9pm. We both slipped off at that point in the conversation where it didn’t make sense to say the same things for the sixtieth time. We still don’t know what will be best.
But like I said, we had a deadline. So on Monday night, we flipped a coin and had a good night’s rest.






43 comments
Comments feed for this article
November 11, 2009 at 2:45 am
Louise Plummer
That’s it? Michigan or Mongolia and we don’t know which one? That isn’t good enough. We want to know where you decided to go and whose first choice it was. For the blog’s sake, I hope it’s Mongolia. I’d like to hear about that life.
Come on, tell all.
November 11, 2009 at 3:16 am
Samantha
I’m so glad I spoke to you on the phone this week Rebecca. Louise stole my comment though- MICHIGAN OR MONGOLIA??
November 11, 2009 at 6:17 am
Brohammas
Who said your choices now determine later? There is a nasty secret people don’t tell you about… you can still change your mind later.
We get so caught up trying to stick to the progression, move on, plow forward, competing with, and measuring ourselves against others of the same generation. Don’t.
Maybe you change your mindff in 5 years and it means you don’t own a house but rent…so?
Maybe you change your mind and don’t progress to upper management…so?
MAybe you change your mind, change your path, and end up happy.
The decisions are only final at death and since we don’t know when that comes, carry on.
November 11, 2009 at 8:55 am
Amanda
No. No. No. You did it all wrong. All incredibly important decisions should be postponed until you are in the middle of labor. At that point, if it still matters to you, you can beg and cry and plead and he’ll give you whatever you want. Or, if you feel like you couldn’t care less about the outcome at that particular moment, then it’s his win.
OK, so my theory might not stand up to critical review, but it’s an option.
And for the record, I thought Michigan or Mongolia was a very alliterative random example of how our choices can take us to very different ends of the earth, not the actual choice to be made. Way to pick up on things, Amanda.
November 11, 2009 at 9:06 am
sarahlolson
THIS was awesome and totally unsatisfying, both. Simultaneously.
You flipped a coin? For real??
November 11, 2009 at 9:33 am
lisapiorczynski
Oh my goodness I can’t wait to stay with you guys this weekend. I’ve needed more drama in my life ever since Mad Men ended.
(Side note– how brilliant was that season finale? Anyone with me?)
November 11, 2009 at 9:34 am
rvs
Who flipped the coin?
November 11, 2009 at 9:45 am
simplysarah
I’m with Brohammas. I have a sneaking suspicion that whatever you choose, you will have worthwhile adventures.
And there’s no rule against abandoning ship if it turns out to be headed somewhere you no longer want to go…at least that’s what I think.
Hooray for flipping a coin and getting the first decision made. Can’t wait to hear what the future has in store!
November 11, 2009 at 10:04 am
Carole
Amen to Sarah and Brohammas. The unfair thing isn’t so much that we have to make so many permanent decisions, but that so many any of them seem permanent. Most of them really aren’t.
A non-binding coint-toss can be an awesome way to make a decision, after you’ve “studied it out in your mind.” If you’re disappointed with the outcome, then you know that you really felt more strongly about the other option than you thought, so you should go with that. If you’re okay with the outcome, then you’ve made your decision and you’re ready to move on.
November 11, 2009 at 10:33 am
Sharon
It’s true: it’s exhausting. And then I think about how this is what I signed up for — exactly to be able to make decisions. I wonder if I knew how much would be involved when I made that decision…
But whether you toss a coin or follow bread crumbs that have been leading you on in the woods or you get a direct answer that you either go with or don’t, I find that I still like having options. If I have to choose (there it is again), I like heavy freedom over being stuck in a corner.
Thanks for the post.
November 11, 2009 at 10:34 am
beckarecka
There is no rest from choices. Sorry to say when you want one. I agree with Sarah, Carole and Brohammas.
I would add that it made a difference to me when I realized it didn’t matter where/how/when I ended up floating again. I am still happy with the family I chose. Home is where they are, whether there is a language, cultural, or geographical barrier to things I am comfortable with. Or an alternative I liked better.
Don’t Sweat the Small Stuff…and it’s all Small Stuff
November 11, 2009 at 10:35 am
nakiru
I’m with Sarah. Awesome and unsatisfying. Obviously, we cannot, should not, will not be privy to your private moments, despite the strange intimacy of blogging. However…
May this be one of those things that you laugh at the stress of 10 years from now. Way to not take yourselves too seriously.
November 11, 2009 at 10:45 am
living in zion
I believe in do-overs. Like mentioned by others, the ability to change ones mind and do something else if it isn’t working out. This approach works great after you have made the important, non-negotionable decisions: Who to marry and children.
Since you have obviously chosen each other well, and your daughter is the cutest thing since sliced bread ( by the way – what was the chosen costume for halloween? I must have missed it) the rest is 100% changeable.
Some brilliant person made some famous statement about genius being 99% trial and error, 1% inspiration. You just never know until you try. If you don’t like it, be a genius and do something else. It is the hallmark of intelligence.
November 11, 2009 at 10:51 am
christine
There have been many times I have looked at my husband and said “Being a grown-up is not as much fun as I was led to believe!” I have been married for 18 years and I am just starting to realize that we will never actually just “arrive and settle.” I saw this first hand when we were trying to find a new job and wondering where on the planet to go, I was watching my in-laws wrestle with decisions about retirement and my grandparents go back and forth about moving and assisted living. 3 generations all playing the same game AT.THE.SAME.TIME. I literally wept because it felt like it would never end!
November 11, 2009 at 10:55 am
Traci
I’m with Sharon, my favorite quote from my Bishop – “Ugg, free agency, next time I get a vote I’m voting no”
I will defend the feeling of permanance. Because there are many choices we make in this time of life where you can’t change your mind (how many children should we have?), or changing will require a mammoth efftort (I know we just spent 100k on vet scool, but I just don’t want to be a vet anymore). I can understand the pressure.
I think about this balancing act alot, where does guidance from the Lord end and keeping your own council begin? We’re supposed to have both, I think, but it’s a puzzle.
November 11, 2009 at 11:33 am
Merinda
Oooh I’m voting for Mongolia. I’d love to read what you’d write about living there!
November 11, 2009 at 12:12 pm
lauren k
Thank you for not telling us the choice yet. At least from my perspective, time to digest this post is exactly what I need this morning. Exactly exactly. Thank you for this blog ladies. You are all incredible.
November 11, 2009 at 12:13 pm
Natalie
I love it. Coin flipping. Exciting.
I always make a decision by making a decision. And if I don’t like that decision then I go with the other one. Confusing? It makes perfect sense to me. hehe
November 11, 2009 at 12:48 pm
Slone
Lisa – I agree about the finale of Mad Men. Though I guessed that Joan would save the day long before she walked through the door. I wish I were a writer on that show.
Rebecca – What a wicked game you play in teasing us. For heaven sake, spill. Tell us what the coin toss is really about.
November 11, 2009 at 12:59 pm
kt
Before my grandfather passed away in his early 90s, we went to visit him in the hospital. He was still very lucid and had always been rather philosophical. As we visited with him, I remember him distinctly saying, with great profundity, “Life unfolds.”
I wrote it down in the margin of the book I had with me at the time and it is something I think of often – the retrospective of the unfurling of life and the patience that I am seeking to embrace in order to accept it with grace.
November 11, 2009 at 1:15 pm
As Sistas In Zion
So glad I saw this post, I have had some important decisions to make and I will now be heading home to get my nickel polished!
November 11, 2009 at 1:41 pm
Hilary
I have to admit, Totally unsatisfied. SO WHAT HAPPENED???? I don’t know you personally but I have been reading the AS for several months now. The whole time I was afraid that you were going to drop the Divorce bomb on us and I was almost in tears…(the marriage counselor mention really made my stomach drop). The suspense was good. While the details of the decision may never be known…I’m so glad that the entry wasn’t code for your marriage ending. I might not be able to take that. You and Levi and Adelaide just seem like such a happy, well-educated, cute Manhattan family. Good luck with adjusting to whatever decision you decided. I used to give myself stomach aches worrying about big decisions (I hear you on that point) and my dad used to say, “Just make a decision and make whatever you decide be the right decision. Just really Choose it.” I thought it was good advice…once I could wrap my head around it.
November 11, 2009 at 2:00 pm
Kaedi
Just ONE coin toss? Add a little spice to it! I prefer the best of seven, or scissors/paper/rock.
November 11, 2009 at 2:03 pm
Kaedi
P.S. Did you decide to move over to that two bedroom after all?!?
November 11, 2009 at 2:03 pm
smylies
Louise and Samantha: we chose Mongolia.
Everyone else: Mongolia and Michigan were, as Amanda suggested, random selections to show that these little decisions do take us to the ends of the earth. Still, sometimes I have to satiate Samantha and Louise and lying is usually the easiest way to do it.
Amanda–I’ve tried the labor thing. IT DIDN’T WORK. Our little Adelaide would be a little Amelia had it.
SLO–yes, we really did.
LisaP.–hurry up.
rvs–I flipped. I called it. Levi won.
Ah Carole, yes, you’re on to me. Just make a decision and then check your gut. It didn’t work this time. We’d both had about thirty gut-checks by this time. Ugh.
And I have to say, while choices aren’t permanent, neither are options. So Brohammas and Sarah and those who echoed–yes! yes! there are chances to back out and try again and start over, but the job offer won’t be there, the children will be too old, etc. Though I do take great comfort knowing that because we get to choose, if things are bad, we’ll choose something else.
Sharon, good call. Choice is a blessed thing, as frustrating and scary as it can be.
Beckarecka–yeah, good perspective. We talked about that too. But isn’t there also this part of you that comes to the decision and says, “I’ll be happy either way, it’s small…but I might be a touch MORE happy if I choose correctly…”
Nakiru–I’ll tell you this: Levi won. He always does. And yes, let’s hope it’s something we laugh about. Not, “Remember when we made that decision and it RUINED EVERYTHING.” Just kidding.
Living in Zion: hallmark of genuis. Yep. Yep. I get it. Still, there’s that nagging voice that keeps showing up in my responses to people’s comments. WHAT IF WE MOVE TO MONGOLIA AND HATE IT AND THEN FIND OUT THAT MICHIGAN NO LONGER EXISTS!!! Le sigh. Life, right?
Christine- Your comment was like my post–I liked it, but it left me unsatisfied. I really, really wish you’d said it would all be over in a few. But I do like the idea of everyone doing it. Let’s all weep together.
Traci, I love your bishop. And you. Anyone reading all of my responses will be able to gather that I’m not in a great mood today. I’ve tried to say what you said in your second line about four different times and it keeps on coming out snarky. From now on, I’m referring people to comment number 15.
Merinda–where were you before the coin toss?
Lauren K–thanks.
Natalie–I love your personality. From three sentences, I know I love it. Come over. We’ll tell you the sides and you decide.
Slone, I have to tease you. I’m up against Sarah, Louise, and Lisa for my ratings. I guess you’ll just have to wait and see… (just kidding)
kt–it does, doesn’t it? Kind of makes me want to stop deciding altogether and see where we end up. BUt that’s a decision too, eh?
Sistas–yes, save yourselves the headache. All pre-decision work should be spent polishing, not weighing it out in your head.
Kaedi–we said just one. Then after it was heads, we said two out of three. It was tails both times. But since we didn’t clearly establish the rules before tossing, we felt morally obligated to go with the heads. It’s awful. All of it. No, we did not decide on the two-bedroom. That option evaded us because we waited too long. See what I mean?
Hilary, I loved your Dad’s advice. Levi and I kept saying that to eachother, “We’re going to be happy no matter what…” (Isn’t that a different way to say what your dad said?)
November 11, 2009 at 2:08 pm
Miggy
I too thought Mongolia or Michigan was more metaphorical.
And before you tell us I’d like to take a guess …
YOU wanted Mongolia. Levi wanted Michigan. Because you’re the adventerous spirit and Levi is more practical and wants to be close to family….
No wait, it’s switched…you want Michigan because you want to be close to family…I mean you’re probably going to have more babies, and who wants to birth in Mongolia? That’s my final vote. Rebecca = Michigan and Levi = Mongolia. And I’m guessing it came out Mongolia!
Also–for those of you who think you can always change these decisions, well sometimes you can’t. My husband is in a 2 year residency in Cincinnati–and if you’re familiar with how the match program works, then you know you really don’t have much of a choice. After this we have a 3 year commitment with the Air Force where again we won’t know where we’re going and really have no choice and we HAVE to spend 3 years wherever they send us or I think we might be sent to prison or something….really, some things are not negoiatable. We’re definitely excited and glad we chose this road, but if we weren’t happy it would have been a long 5 years.
November 11, 2009 at 2:10 pm
Miggy
just for the record I posted my comment before Rebecca posted hers…
so what are the metaphorical Michigan and Mongolia? I’m confused…
November 11, 2009 at 2:56 pm
smylies
no seriously–mongolia and michigan are just to say that while the choices seem small and not that different, twenty years from now, one could land you in Mongolia, and the other in Michigan–
That said, Miggy, your analysis was spot-on. Except for I’m not adventurous.
November 11, 2009 at 3:26 pm
Samantha
Rebecca, you called heads didn’t you? Because tails never fails! (did you always know deep down inside it would end up this way anyway?)
November 11, 2009 at 3:42 pm
margy
MONGOLIA!!! Yay! Sad you went through so much agony getting there, and sad it’s not NYC, but we might end up there with you. Decisions are SO hard for the Elliotts too. Deadlines are good for people like us. The next question is … when?
November 11, 2009 at 3:51 pm
Traci
Kt, that was pretty and I wish I knew your grandpa, he sounds like a really good guy to know.
November 11, 2009 at 6:14 pm
shelley
I’m usually all for Levi winning, but not this time. Couldn’t you have just stayed in Michigan one more year?
November 11, 2009 at 7:50 pm
Kahalia
this is torture…
what is the real decision?
DOn’t you love us enough to tell us al your business?
November 11, 2009 at 8:53 pm
Holly
I’m in favor of Michigan literally, rather than metaphorically, because it’s within driving distance of us. Although I wouldn’t wish a Michigan winter on anyone I love. Can’t wait to hear the story with actual rather than metaphorical details!
Miggy. Who are you? I’m in Cincinnati, but for much longer than 2 years…
November 11, 2009 at 11:35 pm
Brooke
HI HOLLY!
(Shamelessly using this awesome awesome blog to say hi.)
HI LISA!
(You are awesome awesome, too.)
I am not in favor of Michigan. HKHL, come home!
November 12, 2009 at 12:37 am
Louise Plummer
Sometimes I hate metaphors.
November 12, 2009 at 8:24 pm
Marci
This whole idea has been weighing on me lately. Over the course of the past 6 years my husband and I have made decisions we felt were the best for our family. We prayed, fasted, attended the temple, counseled with others, and wrote down all the pros and cons of various options. We didn’t always agree on exactly what to do but we made decisions and moved forward. And then things didn’t work out the way we thought they would, time after time. Are we happy with each other? Yes. Are we happy with our family? Yes. Are we grateful for the blessings we currently enjoy in our lives? Yes. Are a number of options closed to us now? Yes. Can we ever go back and try those options again? No. Would we do things differently if we could go back and change them? Perhaps.
It gives me whole new insight into the scriptural story of Lehi’s family with Sariah complaining, “I know you said we were leaving Jerusalem, but this?! Really? Laban is going to kill our children, we are going to starve, I’m living in a tent, what were we thinking?”
Or Joseph in Egypt, “I’ve done what I thought was right and tried to be faithful but here I am in prison after almost being killed by my brothers, being sold as a slave, and being falsely accused of rape. What did I do wrong?”
Or Emma’s private moments with Joseph, “I thought we were going to have such a life and yet you have no job, we have no food, the mobs keep taking you to prison and threatening to kill you, my children keep dying, and I have no possession and no home. ”
In each scenario I am sure the various people tried to stay close to the Lord, prayed, and made the best decisions they could. And yet each had arguments and opinions, and each had to climb some rugged terrain as they moved through life.
Lately as I’ve been reading the Doctrine and Covenants I’ve been amazed at how much Heavenly Father lets us do on our own. He calls so-and-so to go on a mission but says he doesn’t care where, just as long as the person goes. Or he tells them to go to the Eastern States but tells them to leave whenever they want to. It reminds me of the way we raise our children. We let them go about their lives, teaching them the best we can, and helping when we ask for it, but we don’t tell them what classes to take, who to talk to, or how to deal with every problem they encounter. When life doesn’t turn out the way they want we hug and kiss them and tell them that they are still important to us and that years from now this particular incident will be woven into the other threads of their life and will add interesting texture and perspective.
Our decisions don’t always add the perfect color to the painting of our lives, and sometimes different people add colors that seen jarring and out of place, but we can rework those colors to make the masterpiece we ultimately desire. And hopefully as we look long and hard at that masterpiece, be it in Mongolia or Michigan, will make us happy and fill our lives with beauty and peace.
(Louise, how badly do you hate metaphors?)
November 13, 2009 at 8:27 am
smylies
Marci–that was beautiful. I love the idea that seemingly, choosing the less desirable path (unknowingly) is exactly what we need.
Also, next time I have to give a talk, I’m stealing this from you…
Really lovely. Thanks-
November 13, 2009 at 11:48 am
allysha
Sometimes flipping a coin is the best idea. Also, sure choices have consequences, but I think it’a an illusion to feel like you are going to be stuck on one path because of one choice. Really, there will be a lot of decisions and who knows? They say all paths lead to Rome, so maybe Mongolia and Michigan don’t really exists.
Good luck!
November 13, 2009 at 7:00 pm
Erin Allen
Oh Rebecca, I feel for you and Levi. I really do. This post hits close to home as I have agonized over more than one big decision in my life. I think it’s the responsibility of the consequences that makes it so scary. Mike actually did his BFA final project on the dilemma of indecision and in the process of his research came across a guy who literally flipped a coin over every decision in his life- what to wear that day, where to eat out, where to live, etc. He wrote a book about it, I forget what it’s called. Apparently it worked for him because the pressure and responsibility were off of him since the “fates” decided everything and he just went with it.
I am completely confident in your ability to live a beautiful, happy life no matter where you end up. There’s always another choice, you know? You just make a choice, go with it, and make it right by the little choices you make every day after that. Heavenly Father will never let you go wrong when your desires are righteous. And things don’t have to be perfect (or easy) to be right.
And I want to come visit you if you end up in Mongolia!
November 16, 2009 at 12:55 pm
Sara
40 comments? You really know how to catch your audience!
But really…you should have just asked me. I could have told you it was a good decision to fly me out to Mongolia with you for two weeks to watch Adelaide while you get settled in. Really Rebecca…you are always making things more difficult than they need to be
November 16, 2009 at 1:11 pm
Sara
Also- in case I get married anytime soon, you need to keep me up to date on your decisions. That way I can work around you–hypothetically speaking of coarse.
November 19, 2009 at 1:05 am
Sarah R.
Great post–but completely anticlimactic! I’m just dying to know what is going on. Mongolia? Michigan? For the love–spill the beans!
Pretty please?